🇺🇸 New York City, United States
Compare the 5 best 4-Star hotels in New York City by updated nightly price, Booking.com guest rating and exact location. The shortlist focuses on four-star hotels that balance useful locations, guest feedback and facilities.
Updated Booking.com rates
| Hotel | Area | Guest score | Reviews | From / night |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| San Carlos Hotel New York | Midtown | 9.1 / 10 | 4,305 | $300 |
| The Wallace Hotel | Upper West Side | 9.4 / 10 | 1,094 | $427 |
| The Pearl Hotel | Midtown | 8.7 / 10 | 2,064 | $255 |
| Broadway Plaza Hotel | Midtown | 9.3 / 10 | 1,477 | $297 |
| Artezen Hotel | Manhattan | 9.2 / 10 | 1,467 | $206 |
1 / 5Midtown · St. Patrick's Cathedral and gym
Located on New York City's East Side, this hotel is just 5 minutes' walk from St. Patrick's Cathedral. It offers an on-site restaurant and a 24-hour fitness center.
From / night · USD$300
Check availability ↗1 room · 2 adults
1 / 5Upper West Side · Lincoln Center walks with concierge
Located in New York and with Lincoln Center reachable within a 13-minute walk, The Wallace Hotel has concierge services, non-smoking rooms, a fitness center, free WiFi and a bar.
From / night · USD$427
Check availability ↗1 room · 2 adults
1 / 5Midtown · Broadway theatres from West 49th Street
A boutique Midtown hotel on West 49th Street, The Pearl Hotel is a practical base for Broadway theatres, Times Square and Rockefeller Center.
From / night · USD$255
Check availability ↗1 room · 2 adults
1 / 5Midtown · NoMad art near Flatiron
Featuring modern art reproductions throughout the property, Broadway Plaza Hotel is located in the NoMad neighborhood in New York, 1312 feet from the Flatiron Building.
From / night · USD$297
Check availability ↗1 room · 2 adults
1 / 5Manhattan · 9/11 Memorial access with a gym
Set in New York, 0.7 mi from National September 11 Memorial & Museum, Artezen Hotel has a fitness center and rooms with free WiFi access.
From / night · USD$206
Check availability ↗1 room · 2 adultsExplore places to stay
Choose your dates and guests to compare accommodation around Manhattan, Brooklyn and the rest of New York City.
Prices inside this live map are supplied by our accommodation partner and change with the selected dates, number of guests, rooms and current availability. They are separate from the regularly updated “From” snapshots above.
Explore the New York hotel guide →Common questions
The page uses the public Booking.com destination, landmark or category result relevant to Best 4-Star Hotels in New York City, requires an established guest-review record where available and then checks each hotel's address against the purpose of the page: four-star hotels that balance useful locations, guest feedback and facilities.
Use the trip's fixed plans as the test. Compare strong independent hotels with larger chains, then prioritise room size and transport over an extra lobby facility.
The most important limitation is location-specific. Four-star standards vary and compact rooms remain common at this level.
No. Prices on Best 4-Star Hotels in New York City are dated snapshots for one room and two adults, not quotes for every stay. Demand, room type, occupancy, taxes, fees and cancellation conditions can all change the final amount.
Check floor area, mandatory fees, breakfast, housekeeping frequency and cancellation terms. Also confirm bedding, room area, accessibility requirements, cancellation deadline and the complete stay total directly on the booking page.
Best New York City Hotels with Two Queen Beds. An independent guide to location, value and the practical trade-offs behind choosing this NYC stay.
Best 5-Star Hotels in New York City. An independent guide to location, value and the practical trade-offs behind choosing this NYC stay.
Best Two-Bedroom Hotel Suites in New York City. An independent guide to location, value and the practical trade-offs behind choosing this NYC stay.